Every route Shieldz uses delivers the same thing, the coin you asked for at your address, but they get there in very different ways. The design decides how fast a swap is, which coins it can handle, what it costs and what you trust for the minutes your coins are in it.
The routes, side by side
| Route | Design | Chains on Shieldz | Today |
|---|---|---|---|
| NEAR Intents | Solvers compete to fill your swap | 35 | Quoted 120 popular swaps, best on 64 |
| Chainflip | Native-asset pools on its own chain | 7 | Quoted 63 popular swaps, best on 20 |
| Relay | A solver pays you out of its own inventory | 23 | Quoted 76 popular swaps, best on 39 |
| MAYAChain | Native-asset pools, THORChain-style | 6 | Quoted 9 popular swaps, best on 1 |
| BOB Gateway | Native BTC in, a token on another chain out | 8 | Quoted 8 popular swaps, best on 5 |
| Garden | Atomic swaps (HTLCs) with a filler | 3 | Quoted 3 popular swaps, best on 2 |
Design 1: solver networks (intents)
You sign an intent: "I give 1,000 USDT on Tron, I want at least 996 USDT on Ethereum at this address". Market makers called solvers, who hold inventory on many chains, compete to fill it. The winner pays you on the destination chain from their own funds, then collects your deposit.
- Fast: you wait for a solver, not for chains to settle with each other. Relay often pays within seconds of seeing your deposit; NEAR Intents usually within a minute.
- Wide coverage: a solver can support any chain it can hold inventory on.
- What you trust: the network's deposit handling and that a solver will fill. If none does, you are refunded.
- Pricing: competitive on popular pairs where solvers bid hard; thinner on niche pairs.
Design 2: native-asset DEXs (pools and vaults)
The protocol runs its own blockchain and validator set. The validators jointly control vaults on each supported chain with threshold signatures, so no single one can move the funds. Swaps run through liquidity pools on the protocol's chain. Chainflip and MAYAChain work like this.
- Native coins on both sides: real BTC in, real ETH out, nothing wrapped.
- Price from pool depth: deep pools give tight prices on large swaps; price impact grows with size.
- Slower: the network waits for your deposit to be confirmed and witnessed, then swaps and signs the payout. Usually a couple of minutes after your deposit confirms.
- What you trust: the validator set and the vault design.
Design 3: atomic swaps (HTLCs)
Your coins and a counterparty's are locked in hash time-locked contracts on two chains under the same secret. When the counterparty claims your side, the secret becomes public and unlocks theirs for you. If they never claim, a timeout refunds you. Garden uses this for bitcoin.
- No custodian or validator set holds your coins in the middle; the contracts enforce the swap.
- Slower: each side waits for confirmations, so Bitcoin swaps take around half an hour.
- Narrow: needs a counterparty with inventory for each pair, so coverage is smaller.
Bridges with their own model
Some routes are built for one job. BOB Gateway turns native BTC into tokens on EVM chains, Tron and HyperEVM through liquidity providers, one way only. It behaves like a solver network for bitcoin deposits.
How a router picks
No design wins everywhere. Here is one live race, every route asked at the same second:
| 1.7 BNB via | You receive | Worth | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chainflip | 0.553457 ETH | $1,011 | about 2 minutes | Picked |
| NEAR Intents | 0.55302 ETH | $1,010 | about 42 seconds | |
| Relay | 0.551321 ETH | $1,007 | a few seconds |
BNB to ETH, quoted November 15, 2026 with every route asked at the same second. Live quote.
A router like Shieldz asks every route at the same moment and ranks them on the amount you receive after every fee, discounted slightly for each minute a route takes to settle, so a route that pays a few cents more but takes ten minutes longer doesn't automatically win. Every route that answered stays visible, so you can choose speed or price yourself.
The ranking happens per swap, so it adapts when a protocol's pools get deeper, a solver goes quiet or a chain is paused.
What this means for you
- In a hurry? Pick the solver route; it is usually the fastest.
- Large swap? Compare pool routes at full size, where depth matters most.
- Want native coins only? Pool routes and atomic swaps never hand you a wrapped token.
- Want to know what you trust? Look at which route is filling your swap. Shieldz shows it on every quote, and each protocol page explains its custody and refund rules.
FAQ
What is an intent-based swap?
A swap where you state the outcome you want and solvers compete to deliver it from their own inventory, instead of your coins moving through a pool.
What is the difference between Chainflip and NEAR Intents?
Chainflip swaps through its own pools behind validator-controlled vaults, with native coins on both sides. NEAR Intents has solvers fill your swap from their inventory, settled on NEAR. Chainflip is often cheaper on large swaps; NEAR Intents covers more chains and is usually faster.
Which cross-chain swap protocol is the safest?
Each trusts something different: a solver network's deposit handling, a validator set's vaults, or an atomic-swap contract. The exposure in all of them lasts only the minutes between your deposit and your payout.
Why does the router sometimes pick a route that pays slightly less?
Because it discounts each route a little for every minute it takes. When a much faster route pays almost the same, it wins. All routes stay visible if you prefer the other.